Tuesday, November 17, 2026, saw Matthew Schaefer record a hat trick for the Islanders. Cutter Gauthier had 4 points in a Ducks-Blues goal-fest, while Mikko Rantanen led the Stars to an OT win.
Matthew Schaefer didn't just score for the New York Islanders on Tuesday; he etched his name into the record books, unleashing a hat trick against the Columbus Blue Jackets that sent a resounding message: this kid is a force. It was a night of high-octane offense, stunning upsets, and late-game heroics across the NHL, proving once again that in hockey, you can always trust the numbers to tell a story, but you can never predict the script.
BEST GOALS OF THE NIGHT
CBJ @ NYI
Columbus Blue Jackets 1, New York Islanders 5
FINAL
✓ PICK HIT · NYI 62%★1 SCHAEFER 3G 0A★2 DUCLAIR 1G 1A★3 DEANGELO 1G 1A
ANA @ STL
Anaheim Ducks 6, St. Louis Blues 8
FINAL
✗ PICK MISS · ANA 54%★1 THOMAS 1G 2A★2 MAILLOUX 1G 2A★3 NEIGHBOURS 1G 1A
DAL @ VGK
Dallas Stars 4, Vegas Golden Knights 3
FINAL
✗ PICK MISS · VGK 62%★1 HEISKANEN 1G 0A★2 KARLSSON 2G 0A★3 CONNELLY 0G 2A
LAK @ BOS
Los Angeles Kings 3, Boston Bruins 0
FINAL
✗ PICK MISS · BOS 62%★1 KUEMPER 100.0 SV%★2 DOUGHTY 0G 0A★3 DIPIETRO 90.5 SV%
BUF @ PHI
Buffalo Sabres 3, Philadelphia Flyers 4
FINAL
✗ PICK MISS · BUF 52%★1 DRYSDALE 1G 1A★2 TIPPETT 1G 0A★3 DVORAK 1G 1A
NSH @ MIN
Nashville Predators 3, Minnesota Wild 7
FINAL
✓ PICK HIT · MIN 63%★1 ERIKSSON EK 1G 3A★2 FABER 1G 0A★3 BOLDY 2G 1A
TOR @ CHI
Toronto Maple Leafs 3, Chicago Blackhawks 6
FINAL
✓ PICK HIT · CHI 51%★1 BERTUZZI 2G 1A★2 NAZAR 2G 0A★3 RINZEL 0G 3A
EDM @ FLA
Edmonton Oilers 5, Florida Panthers 2
FINAL
✓ PICK HIT · EDM 53%★1 PODKOLZIN 2G 1A★2 MCDAVID 1G 1A★3 TKACHUK 2G 0A
WSH @ TBL
Washington Capitals 2, Tampa Bay Lightning 5
FINAL
✓ PICK HIT · TBL 57%★1 GUENTZEL 2G 0A★2 CARLSON 0G 3A★3 O'REILLY 1G 0A
CGY @ SJS
Calgary Flames 5, San Jose Sharks 2
FINAL
✗ PICK MISS · SJS 59%★1 WOLF 91.3 SV%★2 BACKLUND 0G 1A★3 CASTAGNA 2G 0A
OTT @ WPG
Ottawa Senators 2, Winnipeg Jets 1
FINAL
✗ PICK MISS · WPG 53%★1 BOUCHER 1G 0A★2 BJÖRCK 1G 0A★3 ULLMARK 95.2 SV%
THE NIGHT
Momentum Watch Tuesday's action validated several high-momentum players, particularly on the backend. John Carlson's monster three-assist night for Tampa Bay saw him perform 98% above his season average, proving his recent surge was no fluke. New York's Matthew Schaefer, with his hat trick, was 54% above his season average, while Anaheim's Cutter Gauthier's four-point effort was 50% above his average. Dallas's Mikko Rantanen, crucial in an OT win, hit 16% above his average, and Minnesota's Joel Eriksson Ek's four-point outburst put him 31% above his trend, confirming strong signals from the numbers.
THE NIGHT